17 Christmas Eve Dinner Ideas Worthy of Mrs. Claus

The Fellowship of Penny Calling Penny
December 15, 2022
17 Christmas Eve Dinner Ideas – Finger-Licking Recipes to Change Your Mood

Disclaimer: Penny Calling Penny is an affiliate website. This means that we get a small commission when you click some of the links in this article. Don’t worry – we’ll never recommend anything we wouldn’t use ourselves.

Looking for the best Christmas Eve dinner recipes? Exhausted with trying to find, plan, and cook your holiday meals? Too busy to browse Pinterest for the best Christmas dinner recipes? No worries, everyone’s been there before.

Christmas is all about family, friends, gifts… and food, of course! But when you’re hosting Christmas, it can all get pretty overwhelming fast. 

The endless search stops here – we’ve collected 17 of the absolute best recipes to share at Christmas Dinner.

Delicious Christmas Eve Dinner Ideas

These recipes go beyond your traditional ham or turkey and would make Mrs. Claus herself proud to serve them. Give one (or all!) of them a try this season!

1. Classic Prime Rib Roast

Prime rib satisfies your palette with an absolute festival of flavors. Enjoy the king of beef cuts this holiday season!

Get the Recipe Here – Prime Rib Roast

2. Crispy, Juicy Roast Chicken

It’s the perfect Christmas dinner recipe – especially when you’re not cooking for a crowd. Remember to prep long before you begin to cook it for a juicier roast and add lots of your favorite seasonings

Get the Recipe Here – Roast Chicken 

3. Creamy Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Who doesn’t love potatoes and garlic? This classic recipe is easy to customize and sure to please a crowd. Add your favorite potato toppings, like bacon, cheese, chives, and more.

Get the Recipe Here – Garlic Mashed Potatoes

4. Beyond Delicious Green Bean Casserole

Green bean casserole is a dish holiday classic… that often goes wrong. This recipe throws bland, boring casseroles out the window for a dish that’ll be gone before you know it.

Get the Recipe Here – Green Bean Casserole

17 Christmas Eve Dinner Ideas - Recipes That Are Hell Delicious

5. Southern-Style Pillowy Biscuits

Perfectly flaky, warm biscuits are a necessity at your Christmas dining table. These too-good biscuits will steal the show and impress your guests, especially when served with savory gravy and warm butter.

Get the Recipe Here – Southern-Style Biscuits

6. Mouth-Watering Cranberry Orange Relish

The cheery color of cranberry makes it a beautifully delicious addition to your Christmas feast. Go ahead and eat it with a spoon – we won’t judge!

Get the Recipe Here – Cranberry Orange Relish

7. Homemade Eggnog

Is there anything more refreshing than sipping on the eggnog in front of the Christmas tree? We don’t think so. This delightful recipe for homemade eggnog will keep you warm inside and out during your celebrations.

Get the Recipe Here – Eggnog

8. Cornish Game Hens

Want to try something a little out of the box? Then, check out these classic Cornish Game hens! A favorite for centuries, these little birds have fallen out of the public eye, but still back big flavor.

Get the Recipe Here – Cornish Game Hens

9. Creamy-Dreamy Mac and Cheese

Who can resist mac and cheese? This classic dish features satisfying cheese pulls and flavors that the whole family will love.

Get the Recipe Here – Mac and Cheese

Christmas Eve Dinner Ideas

10. Maple Salmon

This is an incredibly beloved, popular, and must-try salmon recipe for a reason – luscious flavors give you a big warm hug the minute your palette takes it. This beautiful, healthy, delicious fish can be on your table in as little as an hour!

Get the Recipe Here – Maple Salmon

11. Crunchiest Apple Turnover

Who says apple is only a Fall flavor? This apple turnover is right at home on a Christmas table, and makes a refreshing change of pace next to all the cookies and gingerbread!

Get the Recipe Here – Apple Turnover

12. Caprese Tomato Tower Salad

Spice things up with this Caprese tomato tower salad that tastes (and looks) delicious! The towering touch to this salad makes it an impressive addition to the table, while the colors fit naturally with Christmas!

Get the Recipe Here – Caprese Tomato Tower Salad

13. Easy Meatloaf

This easy meatloaf is a Christmas Eve dinner recipe and comfort food classic – especially if turkey isn’t your style.

Get the Recipe Here – Easy Meatloaf

14. Butternut Squash Soup

This butternut squash soup is just perfection in a bowl! It’s warm, creamy, delicious, and absolutely beautiful. When you’re looking for appetizers and sides that have some substance to them, this veggie-filled soup is right at home.

Get the Recipe Here – Butternut Squash Soup

15. Go Vegan with Quinoa Pilaf

Tangy, salty, sweet, and savory, this vegan-friendly dish is perfect for a Christmas feast.

Get the Recipe Here – Quinoa Pilaf

16. Bacon and Blue Cheese Packed Dates

The creamy, smoky, salty, and sweet flavors speak the language of YUM! There’s no better way to please a crowd than with easy-to-eat appetizers that you can have ready in under an hour.

Get the Recipe Here – Bacon Wrapped Blue Cheese Stuffed Dates

17. Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Seafood never goes out of style. So, the combo of seafood and pasta might overshadow everything else on the menu this Christmas! The red pepper flakes, crushed tomatoes, and rush of white wine give this pasta recipe a unique flavor sure to wow your guests.

Get the Recipe Here – Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Christmas dinner can have a lot of pressure attached to it, so easy recipes are a real lifesaver – especially when they’re so delicious! Whether you’re serving turkey, prime rib, or PB&J, remember that the most important part of Christmas Eve dinner is sharing a meal with the people you love.

Here at Penny Calling Penny, our holiday articles are only a part of our growing library. We’re dedicated to helping you learn to manage your money, no matter where you’re at on your financial journey. Subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss a Penny, and we’ll see you next time – and Merry Christmas from Penny Calling Penny!


Your Financial Success Starts Here


Actionable Tips and Freebies Delivered Straight to Your Inbox! Subscribe Now!

You May Also Like

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments